[Verse 1]
I was a fool to let you in
Knowin' you were playin' with my heart
Thought we were good, I thought we were good
Thought we could make a new start
You let me brokenhearted
From the day your love departed
Boy, this pain can't last
So take me back to when it all seemed so right
[Pre-Chorus]
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you
When it all seemed so right
Whatcha gonna do about it?
[Chorus]
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you
When it all seemed so right
Seemed so right
[Verse 2]
Boy, you were different when you met
Holdin' my heart, you touched so gently
Now I'm cold inside, so empty
You left me
So now when I wake and you're not there
And I gotta face what I had feared
I do what I want without you, baby
It's crazy
[Pre-Chorus]
Sittin' reminiscin' 'bout a place in time
You been playin' on my mind
Memories of yesterday
When it all seemed so right
[Chorus]
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Whatcha gonna do? Whatcha gonna do?)
When it all seemed so right (Whatcha gonna do? Whatcha gonna do?)
Whatcha gonna do about it?
[Bridge]
I played the fool for you, baby
But you stole away my heart
I played the fool for you, baby
But you played your part
[Pre-Chorus]
Sittin' reminiscin' 'bout a place in time
You been playin' on my mind
Memories of yesterday
When it all seemed so right
[Chorus]
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Hey)
When it all seemed so right
(Oh-oh-oh)
Seemed so right
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Oh, baby)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Ooh, baby)
When it all seemed so right
I was lovin' you (Lovin', yeah)
When it all seemed so right (Yeah, yeah, yeah)
Seemed so right (Love)
When it all seemed so right (Yeah)
I was lovin' you (Whatcha gonna do? Whatcha gonna do?)
When it all seemed so right
Whatcha gonna do about it?